What to Read This Winter

 

What to Read This Winter

Murder in an Irish Castle by Verity Bright-- 1920s Cozy Mystery

I recieved a free e-ARC from NetGalley. All opinions in this review are my own and not affected by the giveway.

Lady Eleanor Swift and her ever faithful butler/bodyguard Clifford (and Gladstone, the bulldog) have been invited to Ireland for the holidays. Leaving the ladies behind, Clifford drives through the nasty weather to the castle Ellie inherited from her uncle. Before they even arrive at their destination, the Rolls nearly runs over a man lying in the road. Mercifully he's not quite dead but it's cold and wet outside and if Clifford and Ellie can't find help, he will die. Fortunately, they discover an abbey nearby where the Mother Superior is reluctant to take in the unknown man. She knows her duty, however, even if he is a man, and whisks Ellie and Clifford off to get warm while they wait for the doctor. Ellie believes she sees a man behind a stained glass window but the doctor has not yet arrived. When he does, the poor man expires from his injuries. Ellie is saddened and concerned for the unknown man. She worries he did not die from natural causes but who tried to kill the man and why? Lord Henley never visited the Irish property and Clifford is horrified to find only one old retainer who won't set foot inside. All the other servants have fled over some nonsense about ghosts. The villagers don't seem to know or want to say who the man was and what may have happened. The schoolteacher who invited Ellie to Ireland claims she did no such thing. Who is telling the truth and who is lying?

This book is good to read about now at the end of the year. It features murder and a possible ghost for Halloween and plenty of Christmas cheer. Henelley Towers is creepy enough for Halloween. I bet it IS haunted but not by the ghost that caused the servants to flee. Derrydee is a charming village. I really liked all the color color worked into the story and learning about Irish food and Irish Christmas celebrations. It's a huge difference from last Christmas in Scotland!

The characters in this series are so lifelike. I love Ellie and how much she's grown in the last few years. I suspect the villagers are anti-English but if they take the time to get to know her, they'll see she's not the usual sort of English noblewoman. Ellie takes in everything with wide-eyed delight, like a child. The food of rural Ireland is humble peasant food but she loves it. (Granted, Ellie has traveled to the remotest parts of the world and sampled the most unusual of foods, so she's not fussy). Clifford acts like he's suffering but he's devoted to Ellie and not just for Uncle Byron's sake. They truly are friends. Clifford is more than a friend- he's the uncle figure in Ellie's life since Uncle Byron was murdered. He's her bodyguard, her sleuthing partner and devoted servant too. Clifford is so prim and proper at times, it is very amusing. I missed the ladies and his interactions with them. Gladstone comes along for the trip but he doesn't have much to do. He's adorable as always and makes a new friend, Tomkins, the kitten. They're very sweet together. There's a new animal sidekick, a very stubborn mule only Clifford can manage.

At Ballykieran Abbey we meet the Mother Superior who is very tough and devout. She's reluctant to allow men in her abbey, even half dead ones and servants. From her reaction to the man Ellie brings in, I suspect she knows who he is but she won't say! Father Quinn isn't talking either and Ellie finds him a bit suspicious. He's new to the area but he IS a priest so if he knows something, he's not allowed to tell and if he's up to something bad, well, he IS a priest! This series is pretty cozy so I doubt Father Quinn is a bad person. Maybe just crusty. Doctor O'Sullivan is a bit gruff too. He isn't forthcoming about his patient and he is seen skulking around the village. Ellie suspects Dr. O'Sullivan might know a little something about what happened the the dead man. Constable Doyle is irascible, doesn't like women and seems suspicious of Ellie and Clifford. It would be easy to pin a murder charge on them because they're the only people around with a car and they're new. Yet, she's the Lady of Hennelly Towers so I'm not sure he can arrest her easily. Murphy, the publican and undertaker, is lively and welcoming but also not forthcoming about the dead body in his cellar.

At the Towers, there's only Cocoroan, a faithful old servant. He's cheeky and not in a good way. I suspect he's either a leprechaun or a villain. He seems suspicious to me. Ghost stories? Not setting foot in the house? He is not a good servant. Ellie should have brought the ladies!

Miss Breen is a no-nonsense headmistress/teacher. She's tough on the kids but only because they're very poor and need learning to get ahead. She seems a bit confused though and not all together with it. Unless she's lying. Murphy's daughter Kathleen is a lot of fun. She's the cook in the pub and keeps her dad on his toes. They have a close relationship but I don't think so close that he has involved in her whatever he's mixed up in. Mr. Sheeply Walsh is an old school farmer. He's chatty enough but doesn't involve himself in village affairs - or so he says.

I strongly suspect they ALL are involved in SOMETHING up to their necks and I think that something has to do with the "troubles." The villain was kind of obvious but the reveal was a shock. I wasn't expecting that and it was a little too dark for me. The motive was rather lame. Doesn't everyone else have the same motive? The secondary villains are rather cartoonish goons who threaten and laugh meanly but don't have enough brains to do anything on their own. Otherwise, the residents of the village and town are enjoyable, well-drawn characters. I missed the ladies and Hugh though.